43°37'26.5"N, 79°22'13.6"W
Member Login
Logout
About RCYC
Hours of Operation
Launch Schedule
Guest Information
Pro Shop / Chandlery
Heritage
About Heritage
Models Collection
Trophies & Awards
RCYC Annals (Login Required)
Sailing
Racing
2024 Regattas
Midweek Racing
Tuesday Midweek Racing
Thursday Midweek Racing
TGIF
Race Management Registration Form
Programs
Youth Sailing
Adult Sailing
RCYC Women in Sailing
Athlete Development Fund
ADF UPDATES
KNOW YOUR RULES
Fleets
Cruising Sailors
Canada's Cup
No Boat? No Problem!
Sports
Racquets
Fitness
Aquatics
Lawn Bowling
Juniors
Sailing
Sports
Childcare
Summer Camps
Island Summer Camps
Dining & Social
Dining
City Clubhouse Dining Facilities
Bistro 1852
Crown and Beaver
Galley
Island Clubhouse Dining Facilities
Harbourview Room
Sailors' Bar
Colonel Ovens Room
Verandah
Weddings & Events
Event Booking Form
Membership & Communications
Membership
Trial Program
Reciprocal Clubs
Sailing Rules: Mark Room - When Can You Gybe?
4/19/2022 6:20:32 PM by
Andrew Alberti
| with
0 comments
Trackback URL:
https://rcyc.ca/trackback/e92eecc1-dac6-4266-8e77-71b7109a894c/Sailing_Rules_Mark_Room_-_When_Can_You_Gybe.aspx?culture=en-US
KNOW YOUR RULES
ABOUT ANDREW ALBERTI
ABOUT ANDREW ALBERTI
Tacking II
Publication Changes and Tacking
How to Finish
Required Hails
Penalties and Sportsmanship
March 2024(
1
)
February 2024(
1
)
May 2023(
1
)
September 2023(
1
)
September 2023(
0
)
May 2023(
0
)
January 2023(
1
)
April 2022(
1
)
December 2021(
1
)
October 2021(
1
)
August 2021(
2
)
March/April 2021(
1
)
January/February 2021(
1
)
December 2020(
1
)
November 2020(
1
)
September 2020(
1
)
July 2020(
1
)
June 2020(
1
)
May 2020(
1
)
March/April 2020(
1
)
January/February 2020(
1
)
November/December 2019(
1
)
September/October 2019(
1
)
July/August 2019(
1
)
May/June 2019(
1
)
March/April 2019(
1
)
January/February 2019(
1
)
November/December 2018(
1
)
September/October 2018(
1
)
July/August 2018(
1
)
May/June 2018(
1
)
March/April 2018(
1
)
January/February 2018(
1
)
November/December 2017(
1
)
October 2017(
1
)
September 2017(
1
)
August 2017(
1
)
July 2017(
1
)
June 2017(
1
)
May 2017(
1
)
April 2017(
1
)
March 2017(
1
)
January/February 2017(
1
)
December 2016(
1
)
November 2016(
1
)
October 2016(
1
)
September 2016(
1
)
August 2016(
1
)
July 2016(
1
)
June 2016(
1
)
May 2016(
1
)
April 2016(
1
)
March 2016(
1
)
January/February 2016(
1
)
December 2015(
1
)
November 2015(
1
)
October 2015(
1
)
September 2015(
1
)
August 2015(
1
)
July 2015(
1
)
June 2015(
1
)
May 2015(
1
)
April 2015(
1
)
March 2015(
1
)
January 2015(
1
)
December 2014(
1
)
November 2014(
1
)
October 2014(
1
)
September 2014(
1
)
August 2014(
1
)
July 2014(
1
)
June 2014(
1
)
May 2014(
1
)
April 2014(
1
)
March 2014(
1
)
January 2014(
1
)
December 2013(
1
)
November 2013(
1
)
October 2013(
1
)
September 2013(
1
)
August 2013(
1
)
July 2013(
1
)
June 2013(
1
)
May 2013(
1
)
April 2013(
1
)
March 2013(
1
)
January 2013(
1
)
December 2012(
1
)
November 2012(
1
)
October 2012(
1
)
September 2012(
1
)
August 2012(
1
)
July 2012(
1
)
June 2012(
1
)
May 2012(
1
)
April 2012(
1
)
March 2012(
1
)
February 2012(
1
)
January 2012(
1
)
December 2011(
1
)
November 2011(
1
)
October 2011(
1
)
September 2011(
1
)
August 2011(
1
)
July 2011(
1
)
June 2011(
1
)
May 2011(
1
)
April 2011(
1
)
March 2011(
1
)
February 2011(
1
)
January 2011(
1
)
November 2010(
1
)
October 2010(
1
)
September 2010(
1
)
August 2010(
1
)
July 2010(
1
)
June 2010(
1
)
May 2010(
1
)
April 2010(
1
)
March 2010(
1
)
February 2010(
1
)
January 2010(
1
)
RSS
Sailing Rules: Mark Room - When Can You Gybe?
I have now written two articles about mark-room at a gybe mark. In both cases, the mark denotes a point at which boats would clearly need to assume a different tack to sail to the next mark. We typically call these marks gybe marks, a term for which there is broad, but unwritten agreement as there are no definitions for gybe marks in the Racing Rules of Sailing. Nevertheless, two rules change depending on whether a gybe is required or not.
The diagrams illustrate markedly different possibilities. On the left side, Blue and Yellow are approaching a mark on a beam reach. The next leg is a run. Boats can sail on either tack on the run, so there are two possible proper courses to the next mark, and for neither boat is there any “necessity” to sail one tack or another. Blue chooses one of these by gybing and sailing on port, while Yellow chooses the other and just bears away on starboard.
On the right side, we also have two boats, this time Red and Green, approaching a mark on a beam reach. The next leg is a port-tack reach. The proper course to the next mark is definitely on port tack, so both boats gybe. Part (b) of the definition of mark-room says, “room to round or pass the mark as necessary to sail the course” (the underlining is not part of the rule but the word is significant and should be noted by the reader). All four boats were free to gybe at the mark, but only for Red and Green is it “necessary” to gybe to sail the course. In the case on the left, it is not necessary to gybe, so the gybe and the room needed for it are not part of the mark-room. On the right, it is necessary to gybe, so the gybe and the room for it are included in the mark-room.
Rule 18.4 says, “when an inside overlapped right-of-way boat must gybe at a mark to sail her proper course…” (again the underlining is not part of the rule). On the left, Blue does not have to gybe to sail her proper course. She has a choice of two proper courses, and she is allowed to choose either one. Rule 18.4 does not apply. On the right though, Green has to gybe to sail her proper course, so rule 18.4 does apply to her.
In the second diagram, we see two pairs of boats taking very similar paths. All four boats are approaching their respective marks. Green and Blue are overlapped inside Red and Yellow and are entitled to mark-room. Yellow and Red both head up and try to follow astern of Blue and Green. Blue and Green both gybe and end up in a port/starboard situation with Yellow and Red. In the diagram on the left, the course to the next mark is directly downwind. The gybe was not necessary to sail the course. Blue’s mark-room did not include room to gybe. She is breaking rule 10 and is not exonerated. In the diagram on the right, the gybe is necessary to sail the course. The mark-room for Green includes room to gybe and she is exonerated under rule 43.1(b) for breaking rule 10.
In the third diagram, Green decides not to gybe. The proper course to the next mark is clearly on port tack, so Green clearly has to gybe to sail that course. Green is an inside, overlapped, right-of-way boat so Rule 18.4 applies to her. By position 6, Green has clearly sailed further from the mark than her proper course, before she gybes so she has broken Rule 18.4.
Mark-Room
Room
for a boat to leave a
mark
on the required side. Also,
(a)
room
to sail to the
mar
k when her
proper course
is to sail close to it, and
(b)
room
to round or pass the
mark
as necessary to
sail the course
without touching the
mark
.
However,
mark-room
for a boat does not include
room
to tack unless she is
overlapped
inside and to
windward
of the boat required to give
mark-room
and she would be
fetching
the
mark
after her tack.
Zone
The area around a
mark
within a distance of three hull lengths of the boat nearer to it. A boat is in the
zone
when any part of her hull is in the
zone
.
18 MARK-ROOM
18.1 When Rule 18 Applies
18.2 Giving Mark-Room
(a) When boats are
overlapped
the outside boat shall give the inside boat
mark-room
, unless rule 18.2(b) applies.
(b) If boats are
overlapped
when the first of them reaches the
zone
, the outside boat at that moment shall thereafter give the inside boat
mark-room
. If a boat is
clear ahead
when she reaches the
zone
, the boat
clear astern
at that moment shall thereafter give her
mark-room
.
18.4 Gybing
When an inside
overlapped
right-of-way boat must gybe at a
mark
to sail her
proper course
, until she gybes she shall sail no farther from the
mark
than needed to sail that course. Rule 18.4 does not apply at a gate
mark
.
43 EXONERATION
43.1 (a) When as a consequence of breaking a
rule
a boat has compelled another boat to break a
rule
, the other boat is exonerated for her breach.
(b) When a boat is sailing within the
room
or
mark-room
to which she is entitled and, as a consequence of an incident with a boat required to give her that
room
or
mark-room
, she breaks a rule of Section A of Part 2, rule 15, 16, or 31, she is exonerated for her breach.
(c) A right-of-way boat, or one sailing within the
room
or
mark room
to which she is entitled, is exonerated for breaking rule 14 if the contact does not cause damage or injury.
43.2 A boat exonerated for breaking a
rule
need not take a penalty and shall not be penalized for breaking that
rule
.
Posted:
4/19/2022 6:20:32 PM
by
Andrew Alberti
| with
0 comments
Trackback URL:
https://rcyc.ca/trackback/e92eecc1-dac6-4266-8e77-71b7109a894c/Sailing_Rules_Mark_Room_-_When_Can_You_Gybe.aspx?culture=en-US
KNOW YOUR RULES
This page provides links to a set of articles original published in
Kwasind
magazine. The versions here include animated diagrams. The original articles can be found within the original magazines which are available online back to January 2007.
Articles before December 2020 are based on the Racing Rules of Sailing 2009-12 or 2013-2016 or 2017-2020 and have not been updated to reflect the changes that apply as of January 2021 with the publication of the Racing Rules of Sailing 2021-24. A copy of the new rules can be found on
sailing.org
.
ABOUT ANDREW ALBERTI
Andrew Alberti has been writing these monthly articles in the
Kwasind
since early 1997. They explain the Racing Rules of Sailing. Andrew is an International Judge and National Umpire. He is a member of the Sail Canada Rules and Appeals Committees. The interpretation of the rules contained in the articles is Andrew's and not that of the RCYC or any of the committees he sits on.
QUESTIONS & ANSWERS
Send your questions to Andrew at kyrules@alberti.ca.
ABOUT RCYC:
166 Years of Tradition | World-Class Sailing | Toronto Island & City Clubhouse
LEARN MORE
Tacking II
Publication Changes and Tacking
How to Finish
Required Hails
Penalties and Sportsmanship
Post Archive
March 2024(
1
)
February 2024(
1
)
May 2023(
1
)
September 2023(
1
)
September 2023(
0
)
May 2023(
0
)
January 2023(
1
)
April 2022(
1
)
December 2021(
1
)
October 2021(
1
)
August 2021(
2
)
March/April 2021(
1
)
January/February 2021(
1
)
December 2020(
1
)
November 2020(
1
)
September 2020(
1
)
July 2020(
1
)
June 2020(
1
)
May 2020(
1
)
March/April 2020(
1
)
January/February 2020(
1
)
November/December 2019(
1
)
September/October 2019(
1
)
July/August 2019(
1
)
May/June 2019(
1
)
March/April 2019(
1
)
January/February 2019(
1
)
November/December 2018(
1
)
September/October 2018(
1
)
July/August 2018(
1
)
May/June 2018(
1
)
March/April 2018(
1
)
January/February 2018(
1
)
November/December 2017(
1
)
October 2017(
1
)
September 2017(
1
)
August 2017(
1
)
July 2017(
1
)
June 2017(
1
)
May 2017(
1
)
April 2017(
1
)
March 2017(
1
)
January/February 2017(
1
)
December 2016(
1
)
November 2016(
1
)
October 2016(
1
)
September 2016(
1
)
August 2016(
1
)
July 2016(
1
)
June 2016(
1
)
May 2016(
1
)
April 2016(
1
)
March 2016(
1
)
January/February 2016(
1
)
December 2015(
1
)
November 2015(
1
)
October 2015(
1
)
September 2015(
1
)
August 2015(
1
)
July 2015(
1
)
June 2015(
1
)
May 2015(
1
)
April 2015(
1
)
March 2015(
1
)
January 2015(
1
)
December 2014(
1
)
November 2014(
1
)
October 2014(
1
)
September 2014(
1
)
August 2014(
1
)
July 2014(
1
)
June 2014(
1
)
May 2014(
1
)
April 2014(
1
)
March 2014(
1
)
January 2014(
1
)
December 2013(
1
)
November 2013(
1
)
October 2013(
1
)
September 2013(
1
)
August 2013(
1
)
July 2013(
1
)
June 2013(
1
)
May 2013(
1
)
April 2013(
1
)
March 2013(
1
)
January 2013(
1
)
December 2012(
1
)
November 2012(
1
)
October 2012(
1
)
September 2012(
1
)
August 2012(
1
)
July 2012(
1
)
June 2012(
1
)
May 2012(
1
)
April 2012(
1
)
March 2012(
1
)
February 2012(
1
)
January 2012(
1
)
December 2011(
1
)
November 2011(
1
)
October 2011(
1
)
September 2011(
1
)
August 2011(
1
)
July 2011(
1
)
June 2011(
1
)
May 2011(
1
)
April 2011(
1
)
March 2011(
1
)
February 2011(
1
)
January 2011(
1
)
November 2010(
1
)
October 2010(
1
)
September 2010(
1
)
August 2010(
1
)
July 2010(
1
)
June 2010(
1
)
May 2010(
1
)
April 2010(
1
)
March 2010(
1
)
February 2010(
1
)
January 2010(
1
)
RSS